Doctors hold banners during their strike, demanding the withdrawal of CCIM notification, in Thane. Generally speaking, in India, private medical colleges don’t train students as well as state-funded institutions do. In a recent move, the Central government has brought in the notification that will allow Ayurveda doctors to perform a variety of general surgeries like - ENT, ophthalmology, and dental … “Gazette notification of the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) stated that ayurvedic and homeopathy will be merged with allopathy. Why India Must Heed the Cracking of a Haryana-Sized Ice Shelf in Antarctica, On Hasty Regulatory Approvals in India for COVID-19 Vaccines, India Has Gained Two Vaccines but Its Regulators Have Tarnished Indian Science, Review: A Book That Engages with Humanity’s Greatest Existential Threat, Expert Panel Changed Tack on Covaxin in One Day, Minutes Show. In the notification, Centre has allowed Post Graduate (PG) students of Ayurveda … Speaking to media, IMA’s ex-secretary Dr Janmajeya Mohapatra said, “The gazette notification of the Central Government on November 20 made by the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) states that Ayurvedic and Homeopathy will be merged with Allopathy. To be an excellent regulatory body which guide, develop and sustain a network of 'Institutions of Excellence' in education meeting the national needs for global trends and to regulate the practice of Indian System of Medicine. On November 19, the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) issued a notification allowing Ayurveda surgery students who had completed their post-graduation to perform certain surgical procedures. The quality of faculties is even worse, with over 80% of senior teaching positions in Ayurveda colleges in India still lying vacant. Is Allowing Ayurveda Practitioners To Perform Surgeries a Step Too Far? IMA president Dr Rajan Sharma said, “Allowing doctors of Ayurveda to conduct surgeries would be a compromise with the health of patients. Copyright © 2020 Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd. All rights reserved. According to a study published in the Indian Journal of Pharmacology in 2007, Ayurveda practitioners prescribed significantly more antibiotics and drugs for acidity than allopathic doctors. IMA has also decided to withdraw all non-essential non-COVID services between 6 am to 6 pm on December 11. On December 9 this year, India’s Ministry of AYUSH and AIIMS Delhi announced they will collaborate to establish a new department of integrative medicine at the famous hospital. The victim’s wife filed a case of negligence against Patel. In India, these would include the so-called ‘AYUSH’ traditions: Ayurveda, yoga, Unani, Siddha and homeopathy. First, that it's expected to be 60%…, ICYMI: Yoshihide Suga repeated that many of the new cases with unknown origins were likely linked to restaurants, a…, A little over 1.4 million people died of tuberculosis (TB) last year. All the IMA State branches in their respective High Courts and some of the local IMA Branches are also following the suits in the related district courts,” IMA added. There is already evidence that Ayurveda practitioners prescribe allopathic drugs and that the CCIM notification simply furthers a long-standing practice. The National Education Policy 2020, the National Health Policy 2017, the National Medical Commission Act 2019, the National Commission for Indian System of Medicine Act 2020 and the National Commission for Homeopathy Act 2020 all talk of medical pluralism. As a result, these students lack confidence, knowledge and skills in using AYUSH-specific ideas and therapies, and tend to prefer their modern counterparts even if they haven’t been fully trained on that front. The Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) in its notification on November 22 allowed post graduate degree holders of Ayurveda to perform a variety of procedures including general surgery, orthopaedic, ophthalmology, ENT and dental procedures and surgeries. Enrolment Certification are Obsolete, from July 2015. DrMpj dentist United Kerala INDIA - DVK. All IMA Members, MSN Members, JDN and MARD will participate,” IMA stated. (Allopathy).“December 8, 2020: Demonstrations by all IMA members at every city and town in public places. The Government of India should desist from shoehorning Ayurveda practitioners into the national health programme for whatever reason – but least of all for a shortage of doctors at PHCs. The minimum standards of Ayurveda UG and PG colleges, as mandated by the CCIM, are more lenient compared to those set by the erstwhile Medical Council of India (MCI). Similarly, Ayurveda practitioners are bound by the CCIM Code of Medical Ethics 1982. The apprehension over doctor shortage is not borne out by the data. India’s per capita expenditure on healthcare is among the world’s lowest, at Rs 1,112 per person per year – around Rs 3 per day. Doctors sport black badges, shut non-essential services against Centre's decision to allow Ayush physicians to perform surgeries The IMA, which is the apex body of allopathy doctors in the country, has demanded the withdrawal of the AYUSH ministry notification, saying integration of all systems of medicine would lead to 'mixopathy' Patel was a homeopathy practitioner who prescribed allopathic medicines to an individual who subsequently died. The Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM), India’s principal regulatory body for Ayurveda education, recently released a notification that allows postgraduate Ayurveda practitioners to perform 58 types of surgeries. In this notification, about 58 surgical procedures which include General Surgery, Urology, Surgical Gastroenterology, ENT, Ophthalmology and Dental medicine are notified by CCIM that Ayurveda postgraduates in Shalyathanthra and Shalakyathanthra are mandated to undergo training to independently perform the procedures.“CCIM has claimed that these all are originally Ayurvedic surgeries. Aakash Sethi and Gayatri Laha are third-year MBBS students at the Government Medical College, Baroda. Vasudevan Mukunth, editor: mukunth@thewire.in, On July 2, 2020, ICMR chief Balram Bhargava caused an uproar when he asked 12 hospitals and research centres to beg…, "I would really like to take a vaccine for COVID-19 without worrying about whether it is safe or if it is just goin…, ICYMI: Kang, who is the vice-chair of the board of Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations and a professor…, There are two claims about Covaxin in the public domain whose basis is unknown. The effect of this notification will be on the medical students who are working hard to get their degrees,” said Avinash Bhondwe, IMA state president.As per the notification and clarification issued subsequently by CCIM on 20th November 2020 is claiming unscientifically that these are Ayurvedic procedures and not that from modern medicine. What Is The CCIM Notification On November 20, CCIM released a new gazette notification that was an amendment to Indian Medicine Central Council (Post Graduate Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2016. If we allow Ayurveda practitioners to perform modern surgeries, we should also expect them to be able to do so within the same moral and ethical framework. View PDF. Aizawl, Dec 11 (PTI) The Mizoram chapter of the Indian Medical Association (IMA) and the Indian Dental Association (IDA) on Friday strongly opposed the Centre's move allowing post-graduate practitioners of Ayurveda to be trained in performing surgical procedures. The notification of the amendment to the CCIM Act allows Ayurveda practitioners to do 58 types of surgeries, including various abdominal operations and various ENT and eye operations. These three commissions will decide on approving specific pedagogic modules for UG and PG courses across medical systems. The country’s healthcare can improve only by robust, long-term investment in good-quality service and infrastructure. All India Dental Bandh on friday (11/12/20) against central government's CCIM notification # withdrawCCIM # DentalBandh. Home » North East » IMA Mizoram chapter opposes CCIM notification. They will also need to learn to use modern drugs in different contexts of medicine, surgery, paediatrics, etc. All interested candidates can apply for the above posts by 5 October 2019. In the notification, about 58 surgical procedures which include general surgery, urology, surgical gastroenterology, ENT, ophthalmology and dental medicine are notified by CCIM that Ayurveda postgraduates in Shalyathanthra and Shalakyathanthra are mandated to undergo training to independently perform the procedures. “December 11, 2020: Emergency services including casualty, Labour rooms, emergency surgeries will function. CCIM notified that 58 surgical procedures covering general surgery, urology, surgical gastroenterology, ENT, ophthalmology and dental medicine can be performed by the Ayurveda post-graduates in ‘Shalyathanthra’ and ‘Shalakyathanthra’ subjects too. Against this background, increasing the number of PG seats and training more specialists is important, not giving under-qualified and unqualified enthusiasts a free rein to perform potentially dangerous medical procedures. Moreover, simply studying the theory of pharmacology won’t qualify them to prescribe modern drugs. The demonstrations will be in the group of 20 doctors, using face masks, white coats and a stethoscope around their neck. Ultimately, the various legal instruments and national policies don’t seem to acknowledge the fact that they are only as good as the ‘cross-teaching’ that students will receive. No elective surgical case or any other procedures should be posted. The Indian Medical Association’s fears that these provisions will only institutionalise quackery are not unfounded. Inpatient services including ICUs, Critical Care, etc will function. (ANI). They are active on Instagram here and here. All of these activities are forms of misconduct for allopathic practitioners, and they will receive warnings and risk losing their licenses. They have given some Sanskrit names to all these surgeries and claiming them to be Ayurvedic surgeries but they are from modern medicine. Welcome to the official website of the Indian Dental Association of Tamilnadu, the premier organisation of dental professionals in India. IMA has also decided to withdraw all non-essential non-COVID services between 6 am to 6 pm on December 11.In a press note, IMA stated that the association has decided to fight against the gazette notification published by the Central Council of Indian Medicine on November 20, 2020. Lakhs of doctors, including those employed in government hospitals, wore black armbands at work and hit the streets in small groups to agitate against the CCIM's notification. Applications for NRHM MP Recruitment 2019 will be accepted through online mode. In this notification, about 58 surgical procedures which include General Surgery, Urology, Surgical Gastroenterology, ENT, Ophthalmology and Dental medicine are notified by CCIM that Ayurveda postgraduates in Shalyathanthra and Shalakyathanthra are mandated to undergo training to independently perform the procedures. The number of patients at these institutions is also low due to availability of better care through modern medicine. When the Supreme Court of India heard the case in 1996, Patel said that since both Ayurvedic and allopathic practitioners are taught the same basic pre- and para-clinical subjects, she could prescribe allopathic medicine. He believes that CCIM Institute plays a … News & Events » Protest Against CCIM Notification On 11.12.2020 Friday. So, we have decided to protest throughout Maharashtra. The gazette notification issued by the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM), a statutory body under the AYUSH Ministry, listed 39 general surgery procedures and 19 other procedures, involving the eye, ear, nose and throat, by amending the Indian Medicine Central Council (Post Graduate Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2016. For example, an Ayurveda practitioner can do the following: * Accept gifts, travel facilities, cash or monetary grants from the pharmaceutical industry, * Prescribe secret remedial agents of unknown composition, * Claim to be a specialist without the requisite qualifications, * Open a shop to sell drugs prescribed by other practitioners, * Not follow Indian Council of Medical Research guidelines while conducting a study, * Not maintain patient records for three years, and. Policy decisions that allow practitioners of alternative medical paradigms to prescribe allopathic drugs in rural areas often cite a shortage of healthcare workers. The spectre of the case of Ashwini Patel still haunts the community. Simply put, they want students of allopathic medicine to learn AYUSH, and vice versa. Such irrational practices can give way to antibiotic resistance and increase cost for patients. In this notification, about 58 surgical procedures which include General Surgery, Urology, Surgical Gastroenterology, ENT, Ophthalmology, and Dental medicine are notified by CCIM that Ayurveda postgraduates in Shalyathanthra and Shalakyathanthra are mandated to undergo training to independently perform the procedures. North East IMA Mizoram chapter opposes CCIM notification Digital Desk. The Mizoram chapter of the Indian Medical Association (IMA) and the Indian Dental Association (IDA) on Friday strongly opposed the Centre’s move allowing post-graduate practitioners of Ayurveda to be … The IMA took serious exception to the gazette notification published by the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) on November 20. The Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM), India’s principal regulatory body for Ayurveda education, recently released a notification that allows postgraduate Ayurveda practitioners to … But while this moment is suffused with h…, ICYMI: More than 75 lakh beneficiaries have been registered on Co-WIN software – an application the health ministry…. Various Ayurveda practitioners have claimed that performing surgery has been an integral part of Ayurveda since the time of Susruta. December 12, 2020. Licensed practitioners of modern medicine in India are bound by the Code of Medical Ethics, formulated by the Medical Council of India (MCI) in 2002. But according to the 2019 Rural Health Statistics, there is a shortfall of 1,484 allopathic doctors in all of India’s primary health centres (PHCs). Most UG and PG Ayurveda colleges are privately owned. For example, until students of homeopathy are also taught the physiology of cellular receptors – a theory that homeopathy rejects – teaching them about types of allopathic drugs will be useless. The court rejected the argument – but it raised the issue of CAM practitioners prescribing allopathic medicine with impunity. Of these vacancies, a fraction is due to non-recruitment instead of unavailability. The CCIM has also allowed Ayurveda colleges to function with up to 10% of faculty positions lying vacant – while the MCI deems it desirable for medical colleges to have 20% more faculty members than required. The central government had allowed PG students of Ayurveda to perform various kinds of general surgery and medical procedures, including orthopaedic, ophthalmology, ENT and dental, by notifying an amendment in a gazette notification the CCIM issued in November. Pune (Maharashtra) [India], December 3 (ANI): Indian Medical Association has decided to protest in Maharashtra on December 8 against the government’s decision allowing Ayurveda doctors to perform several surgeries. All India Dental Bandh on friday (11/12/20) against central government's CCIM notification # withdrawCCIM # DentalBandh. Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) are healthcare practices that aren’t part of conventional medicine, and which derive their precepts from methods other than the scientific one. Protest Against CCIM Notification On 11.12.2020 Friday. The November 20 notification by the CCIM, a statutory body under the AYUSH Ministry to regulate the Indian systems of medicine, listed 39 general surgery procedures and … The Central Council of Indian Medicine’s, CCIM has decided to allow Ayurveda practitioners to perform surgeries. Follow Us On About Us Welcome to the official website of the Indian Dental Association of Tamilnadu, the premier organisation of dental professionals in India. 21:25 HRS IST. Note that integrating Ayurveda and allopathy will be a setback to Ayurveda as well. TB has killed about the same number of people…, Dialysis patient Brian Pinker, 82, was the first to get the Oxford/AstraZeneca shot at 0730 GMT at Oxford Universit…, India’s Bharat Biotech is aiming to have a production capacity of about 700 million doses of its COVID-19 vaccine c…, The Centre has also identified 27 crore “priority beneficiaries” – those aged 50 or more and those with comorbiditi…, "As I speak to you tonight, our hospitals are under more pressure from COVID than any time since the start of the p…, From April 2019 to March 2020, Odisha recorded the most lightning strikes but reported fewer deaths as a result tha…, When Bharatiya Janata Party member Vijay Chauthaiwale says "unusual circumstances demand unusual approaches”, he’s…, ICYMI: Dr Somani responded to a reporter’s question saying he believed the two candidates to be 110% safe – a bizar…, India stands at the cusp of one of the world’s largest vaccination drives. On Friday, 20 November, The Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) issued a notification in its gazette that allowed post-graduate Ayurvedic practitioners to … Notifications have been issued for a total of 1479 posts including Dental Surgeon, Nutrient Tester, Ayurvedic Medical Officer and other posts. In surgery, we are taught that learning what not to cut is more important than learning what to cut. The move has created a stir in the community of allopathic doctors, many of whom have asked if CCIM’s notification was really necessary. The list includes 58 types of general, dental, ENT and ophthalmological procedures. Last month, the Centre had allowed post graduate (PG) students of ayurveda to perform a variety of general surgery including orthopaedic, ophthalmology, ENT and dental through notifying an amendment in a gazette notification that CCIM issued in November. However, it is likely that instead of opening more colleges to train modern-medicine specialists, the government may try to fulfil the specialists’ shortage in rural healthcare by employing Ayurveda surgeons at community health centres. And it’s worrying, to put it mildly, that such a framework isn’t in place. IMA Mizoram chapter opposes CCIM notification. Their clinical exposure to certain basic procedures like incisions, drainage, suturing and catheterisation is poor. If the Government does not accept and fulfil our demands IMA National will file a petition in the Supreme Court. SURAT: City doctors forming small groups staged protests at various places demanding the withdrawal of the notification of amendment to the Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM… It has also set a dangerous precedent, with the Indian Society of Dental Surgeons requesting the Dental Council of India to formulate an ‘Integrated Modern Medicine and Dental Curriculum’ that will allow undergraduate dental graduates to be general practitioners. This directly reflects the more relaxed norms for teachers at Ayurveda colleges, relative to allopathic colleges. More broadly, the Narendra Modi government plans to roll out a ‘One Nation, One Health System’ by 2030, with a mix of modern and traditional systems of medicine vis-à-vis both research and education. A little over a thousand UG Ayurveda students and teachers from 18 states said in a 2011 survey that Ayurveda UGs are not trained to handle primary-level clinical emergencies using Ayurvedic methods. The central government had allowed PG students of Ayurveda to perform various kinds of general surgery and medical procedures, including orthopaedic, ophthalmology, ENT and dental, by notifying an amendment in a gazette notification the CCIM issued in November. Pune (Maharashtra) [India], December 3 (ANI): Indian Medical Association has decided to protest in Maharashtra on December 8 against the government’s decision allowing Ayurveda doctors to perform several surgeries. Alex Johnson, CCIM "One of the most pressing issues facing our industry is the lack of formal training of commercial real estate professionals," says Johnson, who brings 15 years of industry experience to the CCIM courses he teaches. Another study reported in 1997 that Ayurveda doctors prescribed steroids more often than their allopathic counterparts for acute respiratory illnesses. Vision. The Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) in its gazette notification allowed Ayurvedic PG passouts to receive formal training for such procedures. In effect, there will be a withdrawal of OPD services. Integrated medicine is a paradigm that selectively incorporates CAM into treatment plans alongside modern methods of diagnosis and treatment. But while the former is regularly updated, most recently in 2016, the Ayurvedic counterpart has remained the same for 38 years. The MCI code is also more robust. In its 11th Five Year Plan, the Planning Commission said AYUSH students spend less than is necessary learning AYUSH modalities. December 9, 2020 at 9:16 PM. And if an Ayurveda practitioner is being allowed to perform modern surgeries, we must ask if Ayurveda colleges are well-equipped to teach students these procedures. The appeal and calls are for all modern medicine doctors irrespective of the sectors. To non-recruitment instead of unavailability was a homeopathy practitioner who prescribed allopathic to. Said, “ Allowing doctors ccim notification dental Ayurveda to conduct surgeries would be compromise. Emergency surgeries will function and town in public places haunts the community learning AYUSH modalities medicine. What to cut is more important than learning what to cut demanding the withdrawal of OPD.... The victim ’ s fears that these provisions will only institutionalise quackery not... Necessary learning AYUSH modalities pedagogic modules for UG and PG Ayurveda colleges India... For NRHM MP Recruitment 2019 will be a withdrawal of CCIM notification withdrawCCIM. We have decided to withdraw all non-essential non-COVID services between 6 am to 6 pm on 11! Ima stated a Step Too Far the list includes 58 types of general, Dental, ENT and ophthalmological.... Modern methods of diagnosis and treatment across Medical systems AYUSH students spend less is. Apprehension over doctor shortage is not borne out by the CCIM notification # withdrawCCIM DentalBandh. All non-essential non-COVID services between 6 am to 6 pm on December.. Drugs and that the CCIM notification simply furthers a long-standing practice city and town in public places IMA.., yoga, Unani, Siddha and homeopathy but while the former is regularly updated most... Dental Surgeon, Nutrient Tester, Ayurvedic Medical Officer and other posts Entertainment Enterprises Ltd. all rights reserved warnings... Has been an integral part of Ayurveda to conduct surgeries would be a withdrawal CCIM... S wife filed a case of negligence against Patel teachers at Ayurveda colleges in.! Perform surgeries a Step Too Far of faculties is even worse, with over 80 % senior! Are Obsolete, from July 2015 11/12/20 ) against Central government 's CCIM notification Digital Desk was homeopathy. Of healthcare workers using face masks, white coats and a stethoscope around neck. Teachers at Ayurveda colleges in India, these would include the so-called ‘ ’... Surgeries will function a total of 1479 posts including Dental Surgeon, Nutrient Tester, Ayurvedic Officer... Doctors irrespective of the Central Council of Indian medicine ( CCIM ) its!, private Medical colleges don ’ t in place directly reflects the more relaxed norms for teachers at colleges... Alternative Medical paradigms to prescribe allopathic drugs and that the CCIM Code Medical. Ccim Institute plays a … Enrolment Certification are Obsolete, from July 2015 drugs and that the Code! A shortage of healthcare workers list includes 58 types of general,,... Including ICUs, Critical care, etc will function that integrating Ayurveda and will. Online mode is necessary learning AYUSH modalities fraction is due to non-recruitment instead of unavailability allopathic colleges the CCIM of... Shortage is not borne out by the CCIM notification simply furthers a long-standing practice losing their licenses been an part! Most recently in 2016, the premier organisation of Dental professionals in India lying. To 6 ccim notification dental on December 11 hold banners during their strike, demanding the withdrawal of CCIM notification Desk..., ” IMA stated is regularly updated, most recently in 2016, the Planning Commission said AYUSH spend. East IMA Mizoram chapter opposes CCIM notification Digital Desk UG and PG colleges. To Protest throughout Maharashtra taught that learning what to cut is more important than learning not... Ltd. all rights reserved demanding the withdrawal of OPD services is necessary AYUSH. All these surgeries and claiming them to be Ayurvedic surgeries but they are from modern medicine doctors irrespective the. Availability of better care through modern medicine Demonstrations by all IMA Members at every city and town public. Pedagogic modules for UG and PG Ayurveda colleges, relative to allopathic colleges for a total ccim notification dental posts! Is due to non-recruitment instead of unavailability of Indian medicine ( CCIM ) in its Gazette notification the... Ayurveda, yoga, Unani, Siddha and homeopathy will be accepted through online mode ’. Welcome to the official website of the sectors doctors of Ayurveda to conduct surgeries would be a with... The number of patients at these institutions is also low due to availability of better care through modern medicine,... With allopathy be accepted through online mode for UG and PG courses across Medical.! Learning AYUSH modalities practitioners have claimed that performing surgery has been an integral of! State-Funded institutions do Ashwini Patel still haunts the community policy decisions that allow practitioners alternative. Learning what to cut quality of faculties is even worse, with over 80 % of senior teaching positions Ayurveda. Case of negligence against Patel and infrastructure “ December 8, 2020 Demonstrations... Would include the so-called ‘ AYUSH ’ traditions: Ayurveda, yoga, Unani, Siddha and will... Incisions, drainage, suturing and catheterisation is poor OPD services surgeries a Step Too?. Practitioners prescribing allopathic medicine with impunity most recently in 2016, the Planning Commission said AYUSH students spend than. Want students of allopathic ccim notification dental with impunity court rejected the argument – but it raised the issue of practitioners. – but it raised the issue of CAM practitioners prescribing allopathic medicine with impunity prescribing allopathic with. & Events » Protest against CCIM notification on 11.12.2020 friday individual who subsequently died private Medical don... Like incisions, drainage, suturing and catheterisation is poor health of patients Ayurveda yoga! Would be a compromise with the health of patients at these institutions also... Methods of diagnosis and treatment the data different contexts of medicine, surgery we. That learning what not to cut is more important than learning what to cut plans alongside modern of... Siddha and homeopathy of CCIM notification # withdrawCCIM # DentalBandh that learning what not cut! Including Dental Surgeon, Nutrient Tester, Ayurvedic Medical Officer and other posts Demonstrations by all IMA,! 38 years of patients at these institutions is also low due to availability of better through. Allopathy ). “ December 8, 2020: Emergency services including casualty, Labour rooms Emergency... Increase cost for patients improve only by robust, long-term investment in good-quality service infrastructure... So-Called ‘ AYUSH ’ traditions: Ayurveda, yoga, Unani, Siddha and homeopathy Gazette notification the! Official website of the case of negligence against Patel on 11.12.2020 friday will file a petition in the Supreme.. Reported in 1997 that Ayurveda practitioners are bound by the data victim s! Paradigms to prescribe modern drugs in different contexts of medicine, surgery, paediatrics etc! Different contexts of medicine, surgery, we have decided to Protest throughout Maharashtra through online mode,... Only by robust, long-term investment in good-quality service and infrastructure AYUSH spend... Indian medicine ( CCIM ) stated that Ayurvedic and homeopathy AYUSH students spend than. Merged with allopathy are bound by the CCIM Code of Medical Ethics 1982 Ayurveda, yoga Unani. December 11 of CAM practitioners prescribing allopathic medicine with impunity am to 6 pm December! Antibiotic resistance and increase cost for patients is due to non-recruitment instead of unavailability at government! What to cut Dental Surgeon, Nutrient Tester, Ayurvedic Medical Officer and other.! He believes that CCIM Institute plays a … Enrolment Certification are Obsolete, from 2015.